Skip to main content

Brooklyn's Coolest Thrift Shop

Brooklyn's Coolest Thrift Shop

Have you resolved to keep your closets clutter free? Or perhaps you are on the hunt for some trendy fashions without paying full price. Brooklyn's newest fashion hot spot The Underground Thrift Store at Plymouth.

It opened in September, this shop is a curated collection of high-end clothing, shoes and accessories and quality collectibles and glassware. Find fabulous brands that have been sold include Oscar de la Renta, Dries von Notten, Anne Fontaine, Chloe?, Michael Kors, Theory, Prada, Paul Stuart, Brooks Brothers, Gucci, Balenciaga, and Issey Miyake. Collectibles have included sterling silver candlesticks, depression-era glass, and crystal.

25% of the store’s net profits will be donated to organizations fighting modern-day slavery and human trafficking. Founded in 1847, Plymouth Church’s first minister was well-known abolitionist Henry Ward Beecher, brother of the anti- slavery novelist Harriet Beecher Stowe, best known for her novel Uncle Tom’s Cabin. The congregation at Plymouth Church will reconnect with its historic anti-slavery mission by donating a portion of the store’s profits to organizations fighting modern-day slavery and human trafficking. For more about the cause visit

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

How to Celebrate Adoptive Parents

How to Celebrate Adoptive Parents

I recently learned that a friend who had been patiently awaiting a child became a parent practically overnight. When I heard about this loving couple bringing home their first baby, it really got me thinking about how to celebrate adoptive parents. We have experience with more

Spiked Apple Cider Pop Ingredients

Spiked Apple Cider Pops

September in the South is, in my opinion, still summer.  The eighties and nineties always prevail and make the traditional fall flavors that I crave so much slightly out of reach. As much as I want to relax and sip on some hot cider, at the moment, I still need something iced. more

Japan Adventure Park Hyatt Hotel Niseko

Japan Adventure Park Hyatt Hotel Niseko

Are you ready for an international ski adventure with your family? This new opened in January 2020, right before the big shutdown.  The Park Hyatt hotel is located 2 hours northeast of the New Chitose airport in the northern island of Hokkaido. We arrived via flight from Tokyo to more

Donations are accepted at the Church House lobby at 75 Hicks Street during regular hours, or at the store (65 Hicks Street) during store hours or by special arrangement by calling the store manager at 917-627-0979.

What they are looking for:
• Great quality, cleaned, seasonal clothing (fall and winter from August to February; spring and summer from February to August) for children, men and women.
• ONLY designer shoes (Prada, Manolo Blahnik, Derek Lam, etc. – fancy designers!) • Accessories: ties, scarves, belts, fashion jewelry • Like-new children’s books • Quality, undamaged decorative objects, collectibles, & glassware
• Please: NO undergarments or swimwear, NO toys, NO furniture, NO household appliances, NO clothing with stains or tears, NO adult books).

The Underground Thrift Store at Plymouth Church
65 Hicks Street
Historic Brooklyn Heights Since
Open to the public every Sunday, 12:30 to 4pm.

Momtrends was not paid for this post.

Related Articles