Ergobaby Xtra Carrier with Original Carrier Comparison

Image placeholder title

Ergobaby recently launched the new Xtra Carrier, an addition to the Original Carrier Collection with longer shoulder straps and an extended waistband. The Xtra Carrier is designed to provide the comfortable fit we know and love from Ergobaby to taller parents.

As a rule, we don't leave home without an Ergobaby Carrier and we've been rotating between the traditional Ergo and the Xtra Carrier. We've talked about how much we love Ergobabybefore. Alot. (Really, a lot.) So, the goal of this post is really to compare the original sized Ergo carrier to the Xtra.

Size Comparison

The Xtra Carrier shoulder straps are 6 inches longer than the traditional Original Carrier. The waistband offers a longer padded waistband and an additional 3 inch in length.

Xtra Carrier Measurements:

  • Shoulder Strap Length Range: 30”-51” (76cm-130cm)
  • Waistbelt Length Range: 34”-58” (86.4cm-147cm)

Original Carrier Measurements:

  • Shoulder Strap Length Range: 24”-44” (61cm-112cm)
  • Waistbelt Circumference Range: 26”-55” (66cm-140cm)
Image placeholder title

Fit Comparison

There's no doubt that the Xtra Carrier will appeal to fathers, but I also really enjoy the fit. Like the traditional Ergo carrier, Xtra Carrier distributes weight between the shoulders and hips. The shoulder straps have an inch of padding and the longer waistband has a quarter of an inch padding.

The Xtra Carrier is comfortable for baby, too. Cradled in a natural sitting position, the carrier provides an ergonomic fit for baby whether riding on front, back or hip. Though Ergobaby doesn't describe it as such, we think the body of the carrier is a bit longer and provides slightly more support up the back of our 19 month old baby. (See the photos below for fit on baby and above to compare size of support area.)

Below you'll see side-by-side photos to compare the fit. For a bit of context, I'm 5'9" tall.

Image placeholder title
Image placeholder title

One thing you can't tell from the photos is that the padded area of the waistband goes nearly all the way around my waist. Anyone a bit smaller than me around the waist, may actually have difficulty achieving an appropriately snug fit.

But enough of the pictures and statistics. Here's what you need to know: my husband does prefer the Xtra Carrier. He's 6 feet tall and, for him, the most notable difference in increased comfort at the waistband. The extended padding makes the difference in his babywearing experience. I'm perfectly content using either carrier. For us, it could easily be the only carrier we need. But, if you plan to split babywearing time with someone much shorter or taller than you, we recommend getting the Original and the Xtra.

Shop! The Ergobaby Xtra Carrier Grey is available exclusively at ($119) and the Xtra Carrier Black is available only at REI for $115. By way of comparison, the Original size Carrier is also $115 - so you get extra size without the extra price.


Considering the Ergobaby Performance? Read our Ergobaby Original and Performance Carrier comparison.

How do you Ergo? Check out our Ergobaby Adventure video.

Image placeholder title

Related Articles